Math Comparisons

Ratios vs. Fractions

"3/5" can be a fraction or a ratio, and the two readings can lead to different answers. Here's how to tell which one you're looking at, and why it matters.

By Anas Ali (Math Teacher)

The short answer

A fraction is a single number that names a part of one whole: 3/5 of a pizza, 3/5 of the class. A ratio is a comparison between quantities. That comparison can be part-to-whole (which works just like a fraction) or part-to-part (which doesn't).

So every fraction can be read as a part-to-whole ratio, but not every ratio is a fraction of something. That second half is where the confusion starts.

The same bag of marbles, two descriptions

A bag holds 3 red marbles and 5 blue marbles, 8 in total.

Part to Part (ratio only)

Red : Blue = 3 : 5

For every 3 red marbles there are 5 blue ones. The total of 8 never appears.

Part to Whole (ratio or fraction)

Red : All = 3 : 8 = 3/8

3 of every 8 marbles are red. As a fraction, red marbles make up 3/8 of the bag (37.5%).

Now here's the trap. If you write the part-to-part ratio as 3/5 and then read it as a fraction, you'd conclude that 3/5 (60%) of the marbles are red. They're not; it's 3/8. Whenever you see a ratio written with a fraction bar, ask: is the bottom number the whole, or just another part?

Side-by-side differences

FractionRatio
What it describesA part of one wholeA comparison between quantities
Bottom numberAlways the wholeCould be the whole or another part
Number of termsAlways twoTwo or more (e.g. 1 : 2 : 3)
Can the second term be 0?No (dividing by zero is undefined)Sometimes, as a description: a team with 5 wins and 0 losses has a 5 : 0 record
Is it a point on the number line?Yes, 3/8 = 0.375Not directly. You can calculate its value (3 ÷ 5 = 0.6), but the ratio itself is a relationship
Can you add two of them?Yes, with common denominatorsNot in the usual way (see below)

Why ratios don't add like fractions

This is the difference that matters most once problems get harder. Two classes go on a trip together. Class A has boys to girls in the ratio 1 : 2. Class B has boys to girls in the ratio 1 : 3. What's the ratio for the whole group?

You can't tell from the ratios alone. You need the actual numbers.

  • If Class A has 10 boys and 20 girls, and Class B has 5 boys and 15 girls, the group has 15 boys and 35 girls, so 3 : 7.
  • If Class A has 4 boys and 8 girls, and Class B has 9 boys and 27 girls, the group has 13 boys and 35 girls, so 13 : 35.

Same two ratios, different combined answers. Combining ratios means pooling real quantities. Adding fractions like 1/3 + 1/4 = 7/12 is a different operation altogether, and using it here gives you nonsense. The same goes for mixing two batches of paint or juice made to different recipes: add up the actual amounts of each ingredient, then form the new ratio.

Converting between ratios and fractions

From a part-to-part ratio to fractions

Add the parts to find the whole, then put each part over it. For a ratio of A : B, A is A/(A + B) of the total and B is B/(A + B).

Example: Juice concentrate to water is 1 : 4. The whole drink is 5 parts, so concentrate is 1/5 (20%) and water is 4/5 (80%).

From a fraction to a part-to-part ratio

Subtract the part from the whole to find "everything else." If 2/7 of a mixture is butter, the other ingredients make up 5/7. Butter to everything else is 2 : 5.

From a three-part ratio to fractions

Same idea. Cement, sand, and gravel in a 1 : 2 : 3 mix add up to 6 parts, so cement is 1/6, sand is 2/6 = 1/3, and gravel is 3/6 = 1/2.

When to use which

  • Use a ratio when you're describing a recipe or mix, comparing two groups, giving a scale (1 : 50), or when there are more than two parts.
  • Use a fraction when you're describing a share of a total, doing arithmetic with the quantity, or converting to a decimal or percentage.

Check yourself

  1. A smoothie uses yogurt and fruit in the ratio 2 : 3. What fraction of the smoothie is fruit?
  2. 3/10 of a class walks to school. What is the ratio of walkers to non-walkers?
  3. Fertilizer A is mixed 1 : 4 with water and fertilizer B is mixed 1 : 9. Someone pours 10 liters of A and 10 liters of B into one tank and says the result is "1 : 4 plus 1 : 9, so 2 : 13." Are they right?
Show answers
  1. 3/5. The whole is 2 + 3 = 5 parts, and fruit is 3 of them.
  2. 3 : 7. Non-walkers are 7/10, so walkers to non-walkers is 3 : 7.
  3. No. 10 L of A at 1 : 4 is 2 L fertilizer and 8 L water. 10 L of B at 1 : 9 is 1 L fertilizer and 9 L water. Together that's 3 L of fertilizer to 17 L of water, so the mix is 3 : 17. Adding the ratio terms only gives the right answer when the batches happen to contain exactly those numbers of parts.